Alfonso’s Pastry Shoppe Menu (2025 Update)
Alfonso’s Pastry Shoppe is a beloved bakery in Staten Island, NY, offering a delightful range of pastries, cakes, and cookies. Their traditional Cannoli, Napoleon, Eclair, and Cream Puff are must-tries, showcasing rich flavors and expert craftsmanship. The Chocolate Mousse and Tiramisu Cakes are decadent and beautifully crafted, perfect for special occasions. The assorted Butter Cookies and Rainbow Cookies are favorites among customers, highlighting the shop's commitment to quality and taste. Reviews rave about the exceptional customer service, delicious treats, and charming ambiance of the shop. From classic pastries to innovative flavors, Alfonso’s Pastry Shoppe is a gem for anyone with a sweet tooth. Whether stopping by for a quick treat or ordering for a special event, this bakery promises a delightful experience for all dessert lovers.
Individual items
Cannoli
In Store made traditional Cannoli shells with our Famous cannoli cream (contains Chocolate chips & Citron pieces)
Napoleon
Fresh baked Filo dough layers filled with our Fresh French cream
Eclair
Fresh cream puff shell, filled with Custard cream and topper with Chocolate
Cream Puff
Cream puff shell filled with Custard Cream
Red Velvet
a Mini pastry slice of Red Velvet cake with Cream Cheese Butter Cream filling and icing
Chocolate Mousse
a Mini Pastry slice of our Chocolate cake with Chocolate Mousse filling & topping
Rainbow Cannoli
A mini pastry slice of our Rainbow cookie filled with Cannoli Cream
Peach Melba
a Mini Pastry slice of yellow cake with diced peaches and buttercream, layered with Raspberry Jam
Carrot Cake
Our delicious spiced cake with raisins, walnuts, & carrot pieces, filled and iced with our Cream Cheese Buttercream
Cannoli Lobster Tail
Our house made Lobster tail shells filled with cannoli cream
French Cream Lobster Tail
Our House made lobster tail shells filled with our French cream filling
Sfogiatelli
Rainbow Crumb Bun
Almond pound cake with a raspberry jam fillingTopped with our in house streusel crumb
Chocolate Brownie
Our chocolate fudge brownie topped with our Chocolate Buttercream icing
VANILLA Cupcake
Vanilla cake with a choice of Vanilla or Chocolate Buttercream icing
CHOCOLATE Cupcake
Chocolate cupcake with a choice of Vanilla or Chocolate Buttercream icing
Red Velvet Cupcake
Red Velvet cake with Cream Cheese Buttercream icing
Tiramisu Cup
Our delicious Tiramisu in an individual cup
Chocolate Mousse Cake
Two thin layers of Chocolate Cake filled completely with Our Chocolate Mousse, topped with Chocolate ganache and chocolate pieces*CAKE CANNOT BE WRITTEN ON: 'HAPPY BIRTHDAY', 'HAPPY ANNIVERSARY', or 'CONGRATULATIONS' SIGNS AVAILABLE UPON REQUEST*
Tiramisu Cake
A delicious layered Lady fingers soaked in Espresso, filled with a sweet Marscarpone cheese & Marsala wine cream. Topped with Lady fingers, whipped cream, cinnamon & cherry*CAKE CANNOT BE WRITTEN ON: 'HAPPY BIRTHDAY', 'HAPPY ANNIVERSARY', or 'CONGRATULATIONS' SIGNS AVAILABLE UPON REQUEST*
Cappuccino Mousse Cake
Two thin layers of chocolate cake filled completely with Cappuccino mousse, topped with a Caramel Glaze*CAKE CANNOT BE WRITTEN ON: 'HAPPY BIRTHDAY', 'HAPPY ANNIVERSARY', or 'CONGRATULATIONS' SIGNS AVAILABLE UPON REQUEST*
Rainbow Cookie Mousse Cake
Yellow cake filled with French cream, covered with our Rainbow Cookies, topped with chocolate ganache*CAKE CANNOT BE WRITTEN ON: 'HAPPY BIRTHDAY', 'HAPPY ANNIVERSARY', or 'CONGRATULATIONS' SIGNS AVAILABLE UPON REQUEST*
Cannoli Layer Cake
Our vanilla cake filled with cannoli cream, iced with fresh whipped cream.Almond slices around the outside, topped with a mini cannoli & cherry
Cream Cheesecake
Our plain cream cheesecake(New York style)
Strawberry Cheese Cake
Our delicious Cheesecake topped with fresh whipped cream & cut fresh strawberries with strawberry jam*CAKE CANNOT BE WRITTEN ON: 'HAPPY BIRTHDAY', 'HAPPY ANNIVERSARY', or 'CONGRATULATIONS' SIGNS AVAILABLE UPON REQUEST*
Rainbow Cookie Cheesecake
Our delicious cheesecake baked on top of a layer of our Rainbow cookies, topped with Rainbow cookies, French Cream and Chocolate Ganache*CAKE CANNOT BE WRITTEN ON: 'HAPPY BIRTHDAY', 'HAPPY ANNIVERSARY', or 'CONGRATULATIONS' SIGNS AVAILABLE UPON REQUEST*
Cookies & Cream Cheesecake
Our delicious cream cheesecake baked with oreo cookies, topped with whipped cream, oreo pieces and Chocolate ganache*CAKE CANNOT BE WRITTEN ON: 'HAPPY BIRTHDAY', 'HAPPY ANNIVERSARY', or 'CONGRATULATIONS' SIGNS AVAILABLE UPON REQUEST*
Brownie Cheesecake
Our delicious cream cheesecake baked on top of a layer of our fudge brownie topped with chocolate butter cream, brownies and chocolate ganache*CAKE CANNOT BE WRITTEN ON: 'HAPPY BIRTHDAY', 'HAPPY ANNIVERSARY', or 'CONGRATULATIONS' SIGNS AVAILABLE UPON REQUEST*
Chocolate Layer Cake
Our Chocolate cake filled and iced with our chocolate buttercream*CAKE CANNOT BE WRITTEN ON: 'HAPPY BIRTHDAY', 'HAPPY ANNIVERSARY', or 'CONGRATULATIONS' SIGNS AVAILABLE UPON REQUEST*
Blackout Layer Cake
Our rich chocolate cake filled with Blackout Pudding, iced with our Chocolate buttercream*CAKE CANNOT BE WRITTEN ON: 'HAPPY BIRTHDAY', 'HAPPY ANNIVERSARY', or 'CONGRATULATIONS' SIGNS AVAILABLE UPON REQUEST*
Red Velvet Layer Cake
A delicious Red Velvet cake, filled and iced with our Cream Cheese Buttercream
Carrot Cake Layer Cake
Delicious spiced cake with raisins, walnuts & carrot pieces, filled and iced with Cream Cheese Buttercream
Strawberry Shortcake
Our Yellow cake filling with Fresh Strawberries & Strawberry preserve, topped with our Fresh Whip Cream*CAKE CANNOT BE WRITTEN ON: 'HAPPY BIRTHDAY', 'HAPPY ANNIVERSARY', or 'CONGRATULATIONS' SIGNS AVAILABLE UPON REQUEST*
Cherry Cheesecake
A NY style cheesecake with Cherry topping
Chocolate Chip Sour Cream Cake
Our moist vanilla pound cake with chocolate chips and sour cream baked throughout the cake, topped with Chocolate Ganache
Cakes
Cookies
1 1/2lb Cookie Tray
1 1/2lbs of assorted Butter cookies(Includes Rainbow cookies)
2lb Cookie Tray
2lbs of assorted Buttercookies(includes Rainbow cookies)
Rainbow Cookies
1lb of our Rainbow cookies
Buttercookies
1lb of our assorted butter cookies *ANY PREFERENCES CAN BE NOTED*
1lb Biscuit Box
A pre-assorted clear container of our Biscuit cookies
Black & White Cookies
Large Cookie
*contains almond flavor*
Lemon Drops
1lb worth of our Lemon Drop cookies